Boy’s vision improves after undergoing Compassionate Use gene therapy in UK for LCA4 (AIPL1)

DJ and Brendan Broadbin came to our Hope in Focus LCA Family Conference with a lot of questions about their little boy’s blindness, and they left with amazing answers leading to innovative treatment for his type of Leber congenital amaurosis (LCA).

The couple traveled from their southwestern Connecticut home to the July 2019 Philadelphia conference knowing their son Jace had LCA, but not knowing the specific form of the rare disease because their 11-month-old had yet to be tested genetically.

Jace with his red backpack and toy car
Jace ready for the day

Jace’s parents introduced themselves to retinal specialist Prof. Michel Michaelides, one of Britain’s top ophthalmologists, a founding member of MeiraGTx, where he is Head of Clinical Ophthalmology, and a conference panelist.

“At that time,” DJ said, “we hadn’t even met with a geneticist yet, but Michel gave us his contact information ‘just to have.’ We then got to hear the panel discussion at the conference regarding the clinical trials that were taking place across several of the gene variants.

“A few days before we went to Boston to hear Jace’s genetic results (in October 2019, three months after the conference), we received the Sofia Sees Hope (now Hope in Focus) newsletter in the mail, outlining the treatments that were discussed at the conference.

“We brought the newsletter with us to our appointment and almost fell out of our seats when we learned that Jace had the AIPL1 variant, and that MeiraGTx was currently working on treatment through the Compassionate Use case program in the UK – we emailed Michel that same day.”

Compassionate Use treatment

Dr. Michaelides is a Professor of Ophthalmology at University College London Institute of Ophthalmology in the Department of Genetics. He also serves as a Consultant Ophthalmologist at Moorfields Eye Hospital in the departments of Inherited Eye Disease, Medical Retina, and Paediatric Ophthalmology.

The professor has discussed the United Kingdom’s Compassionate Use program in a Hope in Focus webinar series episode called “Let’s Chat About…Gene Therapy for LCA,” describing LCA4 as an exceedingly rare and severe form of the disease in which children have profoundly reduced vision from birth.

A special unlicensed medicine is one manufactured without marketing authorization from the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency. The agency only grants a product license once a medicinal product has been proven to be safe and effective. Prescribed products not holding a marketing authorization include those prepared on an individual basis by “special order” manufacturers, according to the National Institutes of Health.

Jace with his face up against the glass of the jellyfish tank
Floating jellyfish capture Jace’s attention

“There is a narrow window of opportunity (for treatment) because the retina degenerates and thins out by the age of 4 years,” Dr. Michaelides said. “Treatment needs to be before 4 years of age. MeiraGTx has manufactured a gene therapy that they are making available under a Specials license in the UK.”

After months of conversations, sharing test results, and talking with the hospital board members and surgeons, Jace received approval for the Compassionate Use treatment in one eye on March 17, 2020.

The family traveled to London, Jace underwent pre-op testing, and the surgery was cancelled: The world had just begun shutting down because of the COVID-19 pandemic.

DJ and Brendan thought the surgery would be cancelled indefinitely, but to their wonderment, they returned in September, quarantined for two weeks, and Jace received the gene therapy in his left eye, which is stronger, on Sept. 30, 2020. He had just turned 2 that August.

Jace in a hospital gown with a bandage on his left eye. He is holding his monkey binkie and Micky Mouse stuffed animal
Jace after undergoing Compassionate Use gene therapy

Before LCA4 (AIPL1) surgery

The couple first began to realize when Jace was about 8 weeks old that he was not looking at them or trying to track toys.

“He was smiling from touch, but never in response to one of our smiles. He wasn’t blinking when lights were shown in his eyes and wasn’t shutting his eyes or even squinting in the brightest of sunlight. His eyes never seemed to move out of that ‘newborn’ stage of being all over the place,” DJ said.

“When we brought him to the pediatrician, hoping we were just being paranoid and this was something he’d grow out of, they confirmed that something wasn’t right and within an hour we were meeting with a pediatric ophthalmologist – kicking off a year-long journey for answers.”

Before his surgery, Jace had minimal light perception and not much functional vision.

“Lights had to be very bright for him to react to, and his reaction was at least two seconds delayed. Phone screens and TV screens were not bright enough to elicit a reaction from him and outside he had to always be in sunglasses because the sun was never too strong for him to look away from.

“With his left eye, we felt like he could have some shadow perception or make out very high contrast shapes and objects,” DJ said. “He had some words at the time, and labeled toys by feel and sound, but never by sight.”

Prof. Michel Michaelides in a black suit
Prof. Michel Michaelides

Post surgery

About a year after Jace’s surgery, his parents – now both 33, with mom working as a market researcher and dad as a sourcing manager for a major retailer’s store design team – welcomed another son. Jace’s little brother, Gio, just turned 1 in August.

Gio is sighted and in awe of his big brother – so much so, DJ and Brendan said he always felt like a toddler to them, missing the infant stage,  because he’s always trying to keep up with Jace.

He learned how to crawl so he could be closer to his brother and now runs out of bed to meet Jace every morning,” DJ said. “Jace assumed the ‘patient older brother’ role incredibly well. He’s even learned to share his most favorite toys and it’s music to our ears when the boys are both belly-laughing as they rough-house with one another and try out their wrestling moves.”

Jace and Gio sitting in a tent at the beach
Gio loves his big brother

Since the surgery, Jace can identify most of his toys by sight when they’re held three feet or closer to him.

“He is especially good at identifying the ones that are brightly colored and his favorite cars and dinosaurs, of course,” she said.

The couple believe Jace gained valuable functional vision from his surgery.

“Our hope was always that the surgery could protect some of the light perception he did have for a bit longer, never imagining that it could lead to anything more.”

Jace’s mom talked about LUXTURNA®, developed by Spark Therapeutics and the only federally approved treatment for LCA2 caused by a mutation in the RPE65 gene, which has demonstrated improved vision in people who underwent the gene-therapy surgery.

“Someone who received LUXTURNA® described vision improvement as regaining ‘pockets’ of vision in the area where the retina remained intact, and this is exactly how we believe Jace has also regained some vision in his left eye. He will turn his head in certain directions to get a better look at what is in front of him.

The Broadbin Family
Brendan, Jace, Gio, and DJ Broadbin

“In terms of being able to better navigate, Jace now bends down to pick up small objects that might be in his way, noticing them solely based on sight, not feel.”

Jace’s teachers have commented he’ll squat down to look under things when he wants a specific toy in the classroom and stand on tippy toes to find things placed on countertops.

“This makes us laugh to hear.”

Jace, now 4 years old, smiles when he catches a glimpse of his favorite people and things.

“It is heart melting. But he also still flashes that same perfect smile when he feels the sand at beach, hears his favorite country songs, or tastes an ice cream cone – so yes, his vision has changed and it’s amazing to experience, but to us he’s always been amazing to experience.”

P.S. Hope in Focus featured the Broadbin family in its annual Dinner in the Dark video in October 2022. Please click here to view.

Living with LCA: Finding Her ‘Light’ In the Kitchen

A recipe for addiction recovery transformed Orly Shamir’s life, and now it’s about to change her future.

Orly, who’s name in Hebrew means “My Light,” lives with LCA4, a form of Leber congenital amaurosis caused by a mutation in her AIPL1 gene. 

The 52-year-old Canadian, newly transplanted to southeastern Florida, takes her Hebrew name literally.

“I am light, and I am vision,” she said. “I want to offer everything I have for others to realize their perfect light and vision is possible.”

As a child she had enough vision to read large print, but in her 20s, Orly’s sight deteriorated to minimal light perception and shadows. In 2014, she was part of a clinical trial in Canada for the Argus Retinal Prosthesis System (Argus II). The Argus II, known as the bionic eye, stimulates the eye with electrodes to transmit visual information captured by a video camera to the patient’s brain. You can read about her experience in the trial here.

“Still, I have true 20/20 vision,” she said. “My blindness forces a mindful clarity through all my other senses and that enriches everything from my cooking and healing, to my service to others.”

Along her journey through the darkness of an opiate addiction, she rediscovered her mother’s traditional Moroccan fish dish, served as part of each Friday’s sabbath dinner. 

Little did she know the importance this recipe would have to her survival.

From 1999, after having her third child, until 2012, she said, “My opiate addiction took a huge chunk of my life away because it

Orly and Amit nicely dressed at Dinner in the Dark 2019
Orly Shamir and her husband Amit (and guide dog Regan at the 2019 Dinner in the Dark to benefit Hope in Focus (formally Sofia Sees Hope).

was a fight. That’s why I want to give back and give light to the darkness.”

It began with chronic pain and prescriptions for Percocet and Oxycontin that offered relief and a false sense of well-being. Domestic abuse led to living in a shelter with her children. Orly finally realized she needed to get off the pills, but she could not.

“It was the beginning of torture for several years. That’s why we have an epidemic with opiates. It takes a lot of strength and support, and I tried three times over a four-year period. It takes everything out of you to get to the other end and never look back.”

Childhood memories of simmering aromas of lemons, parsley, cilantro, peppers, tomatoes and all the spices helped get her to the other side.

She tweaked her mother’s recipe during one of her mom’s visits from Montreal to Orly’s home in Toronto. When her don’t-you-dare-mess-with-ingredients mom left the kitchen, she took the opportunity, with guilt-laced excitement, to add a few more to the pot. 

“Voila, my specialty Moroccan Salmon, the champion of my life was born! At dinner my mom raved about her wonderful fish, and all I did was smile while my soul did a happy dance.”

Years later her addiction took its toll with memory loss and less ability to perform skills. She realized that improving her cognition could be accomplished several ways, including by eating healthy food, especially fish like salmon with lots of omega-3s.

It’s fatty, versatile and widely available, which is why Orly says her dish is champion food for anyone on any recovery journey, whether from illness, addiction or the blues.

“Without knowing it, this spiritually comforting food became physical healing food.”

Blind Ambition

Orly is a gifted chef, a title-holding athlete (Italian and Canadian dragon-boat racing!), a financial analyst fluent in French and a motivational speaker. She has two sons and a transgender daughter, all in their 20s living in Canada. Orly, her husband of 12 years, Amit, and her guide dog, a 6-year-old Black Lab named Regan, live in Hollywood, Fla.

She just graduated from a Florida culinary school with her sights set on developing a YouTube cooking series and a recipe app.

To help finance her project, she applied in January for the Holman Prize for Blind Ambition by making a 90-second video about her project of combining culinary and cooking expertise with her inspirational recovery story.

“Do you know blind people are 40 percent more likely to develop addictions?” she tells viewers in her video. “And did you know proper nutrition is key to recovery? … Although I’ve been legally blind my whole life, I lost my soul’s true vision through opioid addiction and poor health.”

Orly sitting next to her black lab
Orly Shamir with her guide dog Regan.

Orly is turning her recovery story into a series of videos demonstrating healthy, delicious culinary delights, an accessible-to-all recipe app, and input from guest experts to help heal through the art of cooking.

She fashioned her simple and nutritious recovery recipes by using pronounceable ingredients, healthy fats, nuts and seeds and the like.

“It gives us more mental and physical strength because we start to feel better. We’re not as sluggish.”

Orly learned in March that she is one of 39 semi-finalists for the Holman Prize, selected from 109 applicants worldwide. Three winners will be selected in May.

The Holman Prize for Blind Ambition is annually awarded to three blind individuals to carry out a dream project to push limits and change perceptions about blindness around the world. The prize honors James Holman, a Victorian-era adventurer and author who became the first blind person to circumnavigate the globe; he also holds the distinction of being the most prolific traveler in history, sighted or not, prior to the invention of modern transportation.

Each Holman Prize winner receives up to $25,000 to fund a project or an adventure that will make an impact. The contest is sponsored by LightHouse for the Blind and Visually Impaired in San Francisco. The organization launched the prize concept to support the emerging adventurousness and can-do spirit of blind and low-vision people worldwide.

LightHouse CEO Bryan Bashin said the Holman Prize is not meant to save the world nor to congratulate someone for leaving the house. It is meant to change perceptions about what blind people can do.

“This prize will spark unanticipated accomplishments in the blindness community. You will see blind people doing things that surprise and perhaps even confuse you.” 

Previous winning projects include teaching blind people to become beekeepers in Uganda, hosting the first conference in Mexico for blind children and their families led by blind professionals, and recording a documentary series called “Planes, Trains & Canes” about navigating and accessing transportation systems in five cities around the world.

For the next step in the contest, Orly is creating an in-depth proposal due by the end of April. 

“My talent for cooking, my experiences all over the world tasting a plethora of inspiring favors, and my own story of failure, addiction and abuse woven in with courage, resilience and recovery – it was all for this.”

She Made Canadian Medical History When She Received a ‘Bionic Eye’

Orly Shamir made Canadian medical history when she became the first person in the country to receive a bionic eye. 

In a clinical trial six years ago, Dr. Robert Devenyi and his surgical team at a Toronto hospital implanted an Argus Retinal Prosthesis System (Argus II) onto the surface of Orly’s retina.

The Argus II, known as the bionic eye, stimulates the eye with electrodes to transmit visual information captured by a video camera to the patient’s brain. Toronto Western Hospital-University Health Network and Foundation Fighting Blindness provided support as collaborators on the 2014 clinical trial. California-based Second Sight developed the device.

Health Canada approved the system in 2015. It was approved in the United States in 2014 and in Europe in 2011. 

Orly has a form of Leber congenital amaurosis called LCA4 caused by a mutation in her AIPL1 gene. She could read large print as a child, but her vision deteriorated to minimal light perception and shadows in her 20s. Now 52, Orly took part in the 2014 trial when she was 46.

Photoreceptors in a healthy retina convert light into electrochemical pulses sent through the optic nerve and into the brain where they are decoded into images. When photoreceptors don’t function properly, as in the case of people with LCA, the first step in the vision process is disrupted and cannot transform light into images.

Approval for an Artificial Retina graphic

The Argus II bypasses damaged photoreceptors through electrodes implanted on the retina. Following the delicate three-hour surgery, Orly wore glasses containing a tiny camera that converted video images into a series of small electrical impulses transmitted wirelessly to the electrodes. Visual information transmits to the brain’s optic nerve when the pulses stimulate the retina’s remaining cells.

The visual improvement does not equal regular sight, but it allows patients to perceive light patterns, observe whether doors and windows are open, or pick up a glass.

Orly worked with rehabilitation experts, low-vision therapists and consultants from Second Sight. Three months following the surgery, she could detect contrast and recognize the difference between white and black. Because patients receive a form of artificial vision through this bionic eye, they need to re-train their brains through rehabilitation to learn and understand messages sent by the device. It’s kind of like learning a new language.

Orly volunteered to take part in the clinical trial for a year but presently does not use the technology. 

“I worked hard for two years, then decided to not use the system for personal use, as it didn’t provide any benefits as of yet.” 

Orly’s participation is exactly what a clinical trial is all about. She committed to making frequent visits and underwent testing over the course of a year. She knew that the goal of a clinical trial is to see whether a potential treatment is safe and effective, and that, while a trial participant might benefit, the trial’s purpose is to determine if the therapy works. 

“I was prepared in being part of advancing technology for blind/visually impaired people in the future. That’s always who I am,” she said. “I’m 100 percent ready and available to get updates and keep trying.”

All About Clinical Trials

Clinical trials are never done in a vacuum, or in a medieval basement where Dr. Frederick Frankenstein (pronounced Fronkensteen), his pretty lab assistant, Inga, and faithful houseboy, Igor, create a monster. 

While the creature from the 1974 movie “Young Frankenstein” turns out to be somewhat civilized, (see Gene Wilder as the young doctor and Peter Boyle as the monster doing the soft-shoe in white tie and black tails to “Puttin’ on the Ritz”), a caption above that lab team in a slide shown at the Hope in Focus (formally Sofia Sees Hope) second LCA Family Conference cautions: “Regulatory Oversight is Critical!”

Humor credit goes to Ben Shaberman, Senior Director of Scientific Outreach and Community Engagement for Foundation Fighting Blindness. He moderated a four-member panel discussion in a session called “All About Clinical Trials” at the July conference in Philadelphia. Shaberman reports on retinal research for the Foundation’s print and electronic publications. He also presents scientific advancements at local and national events and enjoys working with constituents to help them understand their retinal disease and current research that may benefit them.

Making sure trials are safe

Dr. Wiley Chambers II, MD headshot
Dr. Wiley Chambers II, MD

Panelist Dr. Wiley A. Chambers, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s Supervisory Medical Officer in the Office of New Drugs, said terrible outcomes can happen in trials not approved and regulated by the FDA. 

Dr. Chambers previously cited a disastrous case in which a 77-year-old woman traveled to an alleged clinic to have “stem cells” injected in her eyes in the hope of a cure or at least help for her macular degeneration. The procedure entailed separating “stem cells” from the woman’s belly fat and injecting them into her eyes to supposedly regenerate tissue. Not covered by insurance and not federally regulated, the procedure cost almost $9,000 and caused her vision to badly deteriorate after her retinas peeled away from her eyes.

The FDA assigns an Investigational New Drug (IND) number to every legitimate clinical trial.

“Just be careful when you go to a clinical trial or a physician that it is a legitimate trial,” Dr. Chambers said. “If they can’t give you an IND number, then walk away.” 

The website Clinicaltrials.gov includes trials that do have an IND number and unregulated trials that do not have an IND number. Avoid them. One must specifically ask if they have been issued an IND number, signaling the federal OK to proceed with clinical studies that happen in three phases.

Dr. Chambers also noted that trials are not for the benefit of participating patients. At the heart of a clinical trial is that researchers do not know what’s going to happen. A key word here is equipoise – a balance or counterbalance – of something. 

“We do the clinical trial and find out, does this have some efficacy and is it safe?”

Clinical trials tell as much information as possible, balanced with a doable study and doable patient commitment.

“It’s a balancing act,” he said. “The trials are to help inform people afterward.”

Research studies in humans are for potential therapies; they take 10 years or more to complete and can cost tens or hundreds of millions of dollars.

It took 12 years and $500 million to research and develop LUXTURNA™, an engineered virus delivered by subretinal injections of the human RPE65 gene, a gene that, when mutated, causes a form of LCA called LCA2 (RPE65-LCA). 

Tami in a pink shirt and Michael besides her in a bright orange shirt sitting at the 2019 LCA Family Conference
Tami and Michael Morehouse

Panel members Tami Morehouse and her husband, Michael, experienced firsthand what it feels like to take part in a Phase 1/2 LCA/RPE65 gene therapy trial. Intervention at earlier ages can offer better results with degenerative diseases like LCA and other inherited retinal diseases (IRDs) because photoreceptors diminish with age. 

The Cleveland-area couple talked about Tami’s pioneering experience as the oldest person, at 44, to take part in the LUXTURNA trial and regain some vision.

“It’s a huge, life-changing event for us,” Michael said.

Walking in Philadelphia three days after her first injection, Tami asked her husband if a building up ahead had stripes on it. Turns out, it was a parking garage with spaces between levels appearing as solid stripes. Before the injection, she could not see any part of the parking deck; her ability to discern solids and stripes meant the treatment already began improving her vision.

Tami had some vision in college and walked across the graduation stage by herself.  Michael described her progressive vision loss as, “Go on, go on, big drop; go on, go on, big drop; no diagnosis.

“She was on a path to darkness and she knew it,” he said.

He heard Jean Bennett, MD, PhD, on a Sunday radio show talking about her retinal research on the emerging therapy that came to fruition as LUXTURNA. He called her office early the next day, and said to the audience, “Guess who answered the phone?” (Here’s a link to a story on Dr. Bennett’s presentation at this conference.)  

Seven months later they received an email from Dr. Bennett, with the subject line: “Are you ready?”

Dr. Bennett conducted the studies with her partner in research and in marriage, Dr. Albert M. Maguire.  

In answer to a question about what she was thinking before beginning the trial, Tami said, “I don’t want to go totally blind.”

“In all honesty, I never thought that I’d ever have a shot at seeing … I kind of underestimated my possibilities. I became a much more functional person in day-to-day living. I would see who’s approaching. See my kids, my (softball-playing) daughter dancing off third base, taunting her catcher. 

“I got way more than I anticipated.”

Tami is part of the Sofia Sees Hope Family Connections program, calming fears and sharing her experiences with many patients along the way, including very young ones. 

“Even though huge strides have been made in clinical trials, they’re very frightened, they’re very nervous. 

“Jean and Albert explained so much; they relieved my fears in such a way that I’ve been able to transmit that to families, to moms. It’s a lot of pressure for some moms. 

“Just being able to say that it won’t hurt when Dr. Maguire inserts a needle in your eye because you’re out like a light; that is a beautiful thing because you don’t even know what’s happening to you.”

Tami advised potential surgical patients and their parents that even though undergoing surgery has the potential to do such good by improving vision, they should think about their expectations. “We are comfortable in our own zone; give us a little bit of change and it can throw us off.”

“If mom and dad or older siblings are calmer, the children are going to be more comfortable, too.”

Panelist Dr. Michel Michaelides, a founding member and head of clinical ophthalmology at MeiraGTx based in New York City and London, said clinical trials impact the daily lives of study participants because they’re required to undergo multiple tests, many of which, he said, are boring and tedious.

“We spend a lot of time letting people know what they’re really in for.”

Black and White headshot of Dr. Michel Michaelides
Dr. Michel Michaelides, a Founding Member and Head of Clinical Ophthalmology at MeiraGTx

Dr. Michaelides is the Principal Investigator of four interventional clinical trials and has 10 ongoing ethically approved studies. He is Professor of Ophthalmology at London’s UCL Institute of Ophthalmology in the Department of Genetics and Molecular Therapy, and Consultant Ophthalmologist at Moorfields Eye Hospital in the Departments of Inherited Eye Disease, Medical Retina and Pedriatric Ophthalmology.

Moderator Shaberman asked him what he says about therapy options to people who have lost a lot of vision. In advanced cases of vision loss, Dr. Michaelides said, optogenetics might be a relevant course of action. Optogenetics is the science of making cells in the retina that do not normally detect light, become light sensitive, and thereby aim to replace the lost light-sensitive cells (rods and cones/photoreceptors).

“The idea is to make cells that are not light sensitive, (be) light sensitive.”

Another course is retinal implant technology, also known as the “Bionic Eye” or “Artificial Vision,” in which doctors insert a light-sensitive microchip into the retina to provide a way to detect light. These implants can be placed on the surface of the retina (epi-retinal implants) or underneath the retina (sub-retinal implants). He also suggested the use of internal or external cameras with these implants, saying, “I think there’s going to be greater development in that area.”

Another avenue is stem cell therapies (cell therapies), in which donor cells could be used to grow fresh retinal cells for transplantation into the eye to replace lost cells. 

He also is involved in the development of therapies using stem cells to replace lost light-detecting retinal cells. He has been Principal Investigator of the first ocular stem cell therapy trial, which involved transplanting retinal pigment epithelial cells (non-light-detecting cells) in patients with advanced Stargardt Disease

His clinical trial for a potential LCA4 (AIPL1-LCA) therapy currently is recruiting participants.

Dr. Michaelides’ ocular research comprises 300 peer-reviewed publications and 25 book chapters. One of those research papers came into focus at the LCA conference in July, where an audience member – a mother of a child with LCA2 (RPE65-LCA) – told her story.

“Even after an ERG (electroretinography),*” she said, “nobody told us it was LCA.” 

She said reading one of his research publications on RPE65 put her family on the right track.

“That’s what we took to our doctor,” she said. “So, you’ve been really important to our journey.”